OEM vs generic replacement parts
Results 1 to 2 of 2
Like Tree4Likes
  • 2 Post By Evergreen
  • 2 Post By J3 Driver

Thread: OEM vs generic replacement parts

  1. Top | #1
    Evergreen's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2015
    Last Online
    06-02-2017 @ 07:24 PM
    Location
    Mid-Michigan
    Posts
    740
    Thanks
    88
    Thanked 99 Times in 79 Posts

    OEM vs generic replacement parts

    I should start out with a disclaimer: in all the years I have been around old 2-cylinder tractors, basically since I could stand on the platform of a 60 and see over the hood, I have never actually restored one. I have taken several out of the backs of barns or out of hedgerows, but I have never done much more to them than what was needed to get them back to work in the field save for a rattle-can paint job. Because of this, I have always placed useability ahead of authenticity. I like to think that most of my modifications are both reasonably tasteful, and in the best spirit of what Deere engineers from the 1940's would have done with access to some of our modern technologies: 12volt electrics, electronic ignition, etc.

    THE SHORT VERSION:
    With the correct John Deere muffler, my M finally sounds good and runs better too! Instead of the generic muffler's hollow pa-pap pa-pap, it makes a deeper, more solid wa-wop wa-wop. And instead of the straight-pipe's lack of low-rpm grunt, now I can get into road gear from a standstill using only about 1/3 throttle. I am really amazed at the difference in performance between the generic muffler and the authentic JD part. Also, not to bash Stanley Mufflers too badly, but the JD part is of much higher build quality.

    THE LONG VERSION:
    When I got my M, it had a muffler off of a Chrysler minivan. Being young, married, but so far lacking in the offspring department, I saw this as a bad omen and quickly replaced the minivan muffler with a cheap, generic, Stanley brand tractor muffler. It sounded much better than the van muffler, but the generic muffler never sounded quite right either. I wish I had made a video to show you all what I meant, but the best I can describe is that the tone was wrong and it sounded cheap and hollow. A few years later I tried a chrome stack which sounded fantastic, but I also noticed that I lost a lot of the famous two-cylinder torque due to a lack of exhaust back pressure. The lack of torque meant that raking hay uphill was problematic. On flat ground I could rake in 3rd gear at a fast idle, but going uphill caused me to have to downshift and run in second gear at nearly full throttle... Which means more fuel burned per hour, almost to the point where my massive Model G could have done the same job for the same fuel cost.
    Last week a friend of mine took me over to see his grandfather. The grandfather's old shop turned out to be the local John Deere dealer he ran back before the days of the mega-franchise dealer network. The dealership opened in the early thirties and had originally been the old man's father's, but he started working there about the time the 20 Series were introduced in the late '50's. The parts room, showroom, shop, and office look like a time capsule straight out of the 1980's; typewriters instead of computers, posters of 'the new 55-series tractors' on the walls, and shelves full of manuals and parts diagrams. Bit-by-bit they are selling off the dealership's remaining stock on eBay to pay for my friend's grandparent's medical bills. Some people have a stock portfolio, this old guy had his tractor parts. Anyway, my friend took me back to the parts room where he dug up a new-in-box M series muffler. Not a replica but a brand new, never before sold to the public, still wrapped in oil paper, muffler. The old man was really happy to meet someone my age (30-ish) who is still using an old Deere as a tractor and not as a show queen, so he charged me what the muffler was listed for in his early-1980's suggested dealer price book.

    THE QUESTION:
    I'm going to stick to my 12volts and electronic ignition system upgrades, but I was wondering if anyone else has had a similar experience with OEM vs generic parts? What else could I be missing out on?
    DRobinson and rtgt like this.
    '50 Model M w/electronic ignition, 12v conversion, and a 3pt conversion plus a homemade snowplow, a Deere Model 51 trailer plow, a Woods RM59 finish mower, a Bark Buster splitter, and a few other toys.
    '69 Sears Suburban 14 48" deck and 42" back blade, an estate rake, and a sweeper.
    '07 F250 XL Powerstroke, crew cab, short box, 4x4.
    '85 F150... I finally sold my very first truck after racking up over half-a-million miles on the original drivetrain.

  2. Remove Advertisements
    GreenTractorTalk.com
    Advertisements
     

  3. Top | #2
    J3 Driver's Avatar
    Join Date
    Jan 2011
    Last Online
    Yesterday @ 03:00 PM
    Location
    West of Carlisle PA, At the base of the Mountains
    Posts
    2,197
    Thanks
    124
    Thanked 414 Times in 243 Posts
    Not Deere but when I got my son's cub it had a zenith carb on it. Rebuilt it and I couldn't get it to run right at higher RPMs.

    Found an original IH carb for it which is about the simplest thing ever made. Overhauled it and installed it. Tractor never ran so well. Starts right up and is silky smooth through the hole power range.
    DRobinson and Evergreen like this.
    1998 955, 70A Loader, 54 Blade, 72 Deck
    1995 F525
    1957 Farmall Cub - Technically belongs to my son.

    If it ain't broke, You're not trying. - Red Green

  4. Remove Advertisements
    GreenTractorTalk.com
    Advertisements
     

Bookmarks

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •