Green Tractor Talk banner

1 - 10 of 10 Posts

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
818 Posts
Discussion Starter #1 (Edited)
Hey guys,

I'm looking into purchasing a broadcast spreader for my 1/4 acre. I've got my X758 which is more than cable to handle a rear mount broadcast spreader, or I could go with a walk behind unit that is likely easier to use on my current property. Within the next year or two I do hope to move to a larger piece of property of 3-6 acres. I will be using this for fertilizer, grass seed, potentially drop seeding. No plans to use it for cement. If I'm going to buy something I've always preferred to buy it right the first time, which means it should be stainless steel IMO to prevent issues down the road. I'm open to thoughts as I've never purchased one previously.


The spyker is the only one with metal gears, whereas the other two are a hard plastic/nylon/something scientific.


I have considered the following:

Spyker S60-12020
https://sleequipment.com/spyker-pro-broadcast-spreader-s60-12020.html

Earthway F80PSD
https://earthway.com/product/F80PS-PROFESSIONAL-ADAPTABLE-BROADCAST-SPREADER.ashx

AM Leonard AM100S
https://www.amleo.com/leonard-100-lb-broadcast-spreaders/p/VP-AM100/

John Deere Rear Mount Spreader LP35439
https://www.greenpartstore.com/John-Deere-Select-Series-Tractor-Mounted-Spreader-LP35439.html
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
286 Posts
I would suggest the Spyker, as I've heard others having problems with the plastic gears.

I have a little Scotts (Tru-Green?) and it's been just fine- for my old house back in the day.

Now I have a full acre, and I'm kinda in the same boat. I'm leery of the big capacity broadcast spreaders 'cuz I just don't think it's a good idea to have 75+ lbs. of product up high. My yard is gently rolling, but there are still some surprise holes I'm slowly finding and marking to fill them in.

I'm going with the Agri-Fab drop spreader. It's Amazon Prime, so that's great for me! I like the tires, and the fact that the design keeps the load down low; much more stable IMHO. It is a bit more than the broadcast spreaders, and the application rate is less. I figure if I just go over each L or R tire track I'll get almost 100% coverage.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
11,353 Posts
I'm a little confused... if you want to buy it right the first time why are you still looking at the walk-behind spreaders? Won't you be wanting something you can tow with the X758? As you probably know, Spyker makes the 125lb and 175lb tow-behind spreaders for JD. I have the 175 lb model and while I don't really need to spread that much material, the larger size and wider wheel track makes it very tip resistant. My yard is very rough and hilly and I've had no issues tipping the 175lb unit.

I initially considered the rear "mounted" spreader but there were too many reports of it throwing a lot of material into the back of the tractor as it doesn't have much of a shield.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
818 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
I would suggest the Spyker, as I've heard others having problems with the plastic gears.

I have a little Scotts (Tru-Green?) and it's been just fine- for my old house back in the day.

Now I have a full acre, and I'm kinda in the same boat. I'm leery of the big capacity broadcast spreaders 'cuz I just don't think it's a good idea to have 75+ lbs. of product up high. My yard is gently rolling, but there are still some surprise holes I'm slowly finding and marking to fill them in.

I'm going with the Agri-Fab drop spreader. It's Amazon Prime, so that's great for me! I like the tires, and the fact that the design keeps the load down low; much more stable IMHO. It is a bit more than the broadcast spreaders, and the application rate is less. I figure if I just go over each L or R tire track I'll get almost 100% coverage.
I got to use my FIL's Earthway unit in the fall and it was not bad at all. I just wasn't fond of the idea of plastic/nylon gears despite the warranty. I called them and questioned it and they said it was to prevent corrosion from eating them when dust and particulate got in, if it did. The JD one mounts to the back of the tractor, an x7xx typically weighs 900lbs without the deck and operator. Despite the additional height and the 75lbs I highly doubt it will screw with the CG and cause it to roll over. You'll be using drop spreader for all fertilizer and seed duties?



I'm a little confused... if you want to buy it right the first time why are you still looking at the walk-behind spreaders? Won't you be wanting something you can tow with the X758? As you probably know, Spyker makes the 125lb and 175lb tow-behind spreaders for JD. I have the 175 lb model and while I don't really need to spread that much material, the larger size and wider wheel track makes it very tip resistant. My yard is very rough and hilly and I've had no issues tipping the 175lb unit.

I initially considered the rear "mounted" spreader but there were too many reports of it throwing a lot of material into the back of the tractor as it doesn't have much of a shield.

Valid point jgayman, valid point. Buying a really nice walk behind would be counter productive if I was going to get a larger lawn in the near future. If I was to do the rear mounted spreader a shield would have to be fabricated like so many others have done as a result of the mess it leaves under the seat....now buying it just sounds stupid. :banged:

I was staying away from the tow behinds because I wasn't sure about stability. Like you said the larger spyker might be much more stable. My last concern was how maneuverable it was when on smaller pieces of property and around flower beds etc. You've definitely given my something better to consider.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
11,353 Posts
I was staying away from the tow behinds because I wasn't sure about stability. Like you said the larger spyker might be much more stable. My last concern was how maneuverable it was when on smaller pieces of property and around flower beds etc. You've definitely given my something better to consider.
I have less than 1 acre and find the 175 lb. tow-behind very maneuverable behind my X500. However, if working around flower beds and other areas where you do not want material spread, any broadcast spreader can be a problem... even a walk-behind. This is because the spread pattern is very wide and with most materials you have a hard time seeing it coming out of the spreader. So keeping it out of unwanted areas in a congested environment is very difficult. The JD mounted electric spreader is the worst in this case because the motor does not have a speed control. (Note: I believe Spyker makes a speed control for a larger unit but it is VERY expensive).

The only real solution would be a drop spreader. It will take more passes because the material application isn't any wider than the spreader but you can run right beside flower beds and sidewalks with no over shoot. Also, most drop spreaders sit low so roll overs are usually not a concern.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,837 Posts
If you had the 3pt and pto you could go with a bigger spreader.
 

Attachments

·
Registered
Joined
·
913 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,228 Posts
Here are a couple pictures of my tow behind JD spreader. From what I remember it was the most expensive model JD sold. Think it was around $450 new. It's rated for 175 lbs but I regularly put 4-50 lbs of salt into it. Salt is the only thing I ever used it for. You can adjust how fast the material comes out by adjusting a knob. The towing speed also has something to do with it. The faster you go the wider it spreads. Had to add the mat to keep the salt off the back of the tractor.
This model doesn't have the plastic drive gears to drive the spinner. The gear box also has grease fittings to add lube.
This unit will not flip over when hooked up to the tractor. The hitch won't let it. Believe me I tried. lol
 

Attachments

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
818 Posts
Discussion Starter #9
Here are a couple pictures of my tow behind JD spreader. From what I remember it was the most expensive model JD sold. Think it was around $450 new. It's rated for 175 lbs but I regularly put 4-50 lbs of salt into it. Salt is the only thing I ever used it for. You can adjust how fast the material comes out by adjusting a knob. The towing speed also has something to do with it. The faster you go the wider it spreads. Had to add the mat to keep the salt off the back of the tractor.
This model doesn't have the plastic drive gears to drive the spinner. The gear box also has grease fittings to add lube.
This unit will not flip over when hooked up to the tractor. The hitch won't let it. Believe me I tried. lol
Thanks for that review. I’m still the the market. Might borrow my father in laws push model one more time. The QH, plow and Front dethatcher and wings are sucking down my spring budget.


Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
913 Posts
Your original post describes my own situation fairly closely. I lived on 1/4 acre in the suburbs before finally moving to a 5 acre small horse farm. The Frontier PTO driven spreader I have now would have been way too much for the 1/4 acre. I'd have broadcasted into the street and neighbor's yards, and all over the driveway and the patio. Most of what I spread would have been wasted. Plus the small amount of fertilizer needed for 1/4 acre was eaasy to spread with a push type broadcast spreader, and I used a drop spreader for years with no problems.

But now with 5 acreas of mostly pasture I spread 1/2 ton or more fertilizer at a time, and also there's the ton or so of pelletized lime every year. So the PTO spreader is the best option.

I don't think that a spreader for 1/4 acre willl do the job for you when you move and have 20 times more land to cover. And a spreader that will do the job efficiently for 5 acres is just too much for 1/4 acre.
 
1 - 10 of 10 Posts
Top