Green Tractor Talk banner

1 - 20 of 67 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,936 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Last thursday, my neighbor came over and pointed out a pine tree "just on my side of the property line" that was "dead". I went and looked at it and it looked dead, but it still had pine needles and full bark on it, but the pine needles were all brown. I told him that I'd call the tree service that I've used and been very happy with and head out of town for the weekend. Fast forward to yesterday, I come home to find that the neighbor has hired a tree service and is having 15 trees cut down. 1 of which is the one supposedly on my property. It has already been cut and I am informed that I owe $400.00. The crazy neighbor is cutting the other 14 trees, "before they die". The tree service that he picked doesn't top trees. They just use a Bobcat and push on it while cutting the tree. Using this master skill they have dropped two trees on my property damaging my other trees on the way down.

So that's the info and the end of my rant. Now my questions. What is my recourse? I have to live next to these people, I've already voiced my displeasure about the situation. I'm fine with taking care of dead trees on my property, but I wanted to use the company that I'm comfortable with. What about the damage to my property from this tree service? Crazy neighbor is very apologetic, but this is pretty ridiculous.
 

·
Super Moderator
Joined
·
5,113 Posts
You'd have to check the State laws there in GA.

If something like that had been done up here in MA not only would you not be liable for the cost, you could have the neighbor arrested and he'd be subject to both fines and jail time. Cutting down someone else's tree is a criminal offense up here. On top of that, you'd be able to sue your neighbor for up to 3x the cost of replacing trees/repairing any damage they caused.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
269 Posts
Cut 14 trees before they die? Sounds like he just wants a better view, or else he just wants to be a jerk or he's that crazy.

It also sounds as if he hired some amatuers. I have never seen a tree professional push while cutting. I bet one day that goes real bad for them. Here they pull sometimes (with rope), but never push. Maybe threaten legal action against his tree contractor, that may scare them away at least. May buy you some time if nothing else.

It sounds like you'll need a good fence, maybe a lawyer, a survey, maybe a court order even. But if he's crazy none of that will work. I have no real advice, anything I suggest would be illegal. Cutting my trees is an act of war and might be handled as such.
 

·
Senior GTT Super Slacker
Joined
·
37,517 Posts
People are all different. If you like the neighbor and are on good terms with them tell them they owe ya one and you are not paying for the tree they cut down on your property or the mess they made.
How does your neighbor know you didn't have your tree sold for lumber?
 

·
Bonehead Club Lackey
Joined
·
10,266 Posts
Last thursday, my neighbor came over and pointed out a pine tree "just on my side of the property line" that was "dead". I went and looked at it and it looked dead, but it still had pine needles and full bark on it, but the pine needles were all brown. I told him that I'd call the tree service that I've used and been very happy with and head out of town for the weekend. Fast forward to yesterday, I come home to find that the neighbor has hired a tree service and is having 15 trees cut down. 1 of which is the one supposedly on my property. It has already been cut and I am informed that I owe $400.00. The crazy neighbor is cutting the other 14 trees, "before they die". The tree service that he picked doesn't top trees. They just use a Bobcat and push on it while cutting the tree. Using this master skill they have dropped two trees on my property damaging my other trees on the way down.

So that's the info and the end of my rant. Now my questions. What is my recourse? I have to live next to these people, I've already voiced my displeasure about the situation. I'm fine with taking care of dead trees on my property, but I wanted to use the company that I'm comfortable with. What about the damage to my property from this tree service? Crazy neighbor is very apologetic, but this is pretty ridiculous.
If it was me I'd just tell him he has to eat the $400.00 for the damage that was done to my other trees. If he wanted to take me to court I'd also inform him that I would then go after him for the damage and for cutting down my tree and for the replacement cost to replant. But that's just me. His home owners insurance will pay you a settlement fee should you want to except it. I cut a tree down that was 3/4th on my property and got sued for it and my home owners insurance paid so they didn't have to go to court.:treehugger: The good old American way?!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
144 Posts
my blood is boiling just reading this!! this "tree service" is not lagit because no tree service would go on a neighbors property without written permission. Neighbor is def in the wrong but you have three options. one pay the 400 keep things civil int he neighborhood while telling him your not pleased. 2 tell him to eat the 400 he will be p.oed but at least he is not walking all over you. three you tell him to eat it and you take him to civil court for the money and leave the criminal court out (make it hurt not permanent).

Me i would go option 2 to keep the peace but if it escalates i would go to three or he will walk all over you in the future.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
365 Posts
This has me so angry, I should probably wait an hour before I respond, but in my opinion you don't owe him anything at all. He dropped a tree that he claims is on your side of the line, however do you know where your boundary line is? If this is your tree, he removed it without your permission. Second they used your property to fall a couple of his trees, again without your permission. And third, they damaged your trees in the process. Tell neighbor to pound sand.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
144 Posts
i knew i liked GTT!:nunu:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,788 Posts
He had no right written or otherwise to remove your tree - period.

You don't owe him anything because you didn't authorize him to do the work on your property. If he was hiring a service, what he should have done was informed you of this and given you the option of using his service (to combine the work.) But seeing as how he just did this on his own - he'd eat the cost for that tree.

Secondly - if the service was on your property without any kind of permission and caused damage - go after or sue (if necessary) the tree service for the costs to repair the damage done. Your neighbor didn't do the damage, the service did. If they are reputable (sounds a little iffy at this point) they should have been properly insured to cover any oops that may occur during work. You should contact them and advise them that they cut down a tree on your property without permission/authorization. (they may even waive the $400 to cut down that tree.)

I wouldn't pay a dime, especially if I had told the neighbor I was hiring my own service (or in my case - using my own chainsaw, etc. to remove the tree in the manner of my choosing....if fact I have a pine tree doing exactly the same thing that I'll be cutting down at some point.)

He took it upon himself to remove the tree without your permission - he absorbs the cost. Damage that occurs on the property is considered vandalism/negligence on the part of the company that was on your property without the landowners (your) permission.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
967 Posts
what ever you do... make memo's for record and put everything in writing to your neighbor and defiantly make copies to your lawyer just in case. :usa
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
144 Posts
there is always the run-a-way deere option........:munch:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
732 Posts
He had no right written or otherwise to remove your tree - period.

You don't owe him anything because you didn't authorize him to do the work on your property. If he was hiring a service, what he should have done was informed you of this and given you the option of using his service (to combine the work.) But seeing as how he just did this on his own - he'd eat the cost for that tree.

Secondly - if the service was on your property without any kind of permission and caused damage - go after or sue (if necessary) the tree service for the costs to repair the damage done. Your neighbor didn't do the damage, the service did. If they are reputable (sounds a little iffy at this point) they should have been properly insured to cover any oops that may occur during work. You should contact them and advise them that they cut down a tree on your property without permission/authorization. (they may even waive the $400 to cut down that tree.)

I wouldn't pay a dime, especially if I had told the neighbor I was hiring my own service (or in my case - using my own chainsaw, etc. to remove the tree in the manner of my choosing....if fact I have a pine tree doing exactly the same thing that I'll be cutting down at some point.)

He took it upon himself to remove the tree without your permission - he absorbs the cost. Damage that occurs on the property is considered vandalism/negligence on the part of the company that was on your property without the landowners (your) permission.
Of all the options I had in my head, I do like this option as a first response. Call up the tree company and explain to them what they have done.
And have others have said, I would not be paying the neighbor anything just yet.

But let's be sure that's also what you owe. 13 trees x $400 = $5200 given a variation of size into the price per. Is this what he paid?
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,788 Posts
FWIW....My parents had a service come in and remove some trees - they were charged $100/tree and they were pretty big and close to the house.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
144 Posts
maybe to drop them (still way cheap) but not to clean them up
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,788 Posts
maybe to drop them (still way cheap) but not to clean them up
They did everything - It was a Dad and his kid (teenager) Removed 5 trees for $500 total.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,160 Posts
He set you up....I'm pretty sure off it...by pointing out that tree. I'll bet a dollar to a donut that 400.00 is going to offset a lot of his bill.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,788 Posts
He set you up....I'm pretty sure off it...by pointing out that tree. I'll bet a dollar to a donut that 400.00 is going to offset a lot of his bill.
If it were me - I'd be willing to bet that $400 he wants me to pay wouldn't offset his bill at all - because I wouldn't be paying it.

Without a written or (at a minimum) an oral contract - he's got NOTHING to use to get that payment.

Let him take it to The People's Court so old what's her face can yell at the guy.:laugh:
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,788 Posts
You are talking about Judge Judy, and yes - she would be on your side. I'll stay tuned....:munch:
Yep - that's the one.:lol:
 
1 - 20 of 67 Posts
Top