Not necessarily.The reason I say it was good is because its only about 2 yrs old and I know that doesn't man anything and I always 100% of time keep a battery tender on it when not in use. So even after I charged and jumped it with my jump box the solenoid clicked but no start. So do you still think it is battery or could it be solenoid? If battery was bad it should have started with the jump box or not? Appreciate all your reply's and suggestions.