Green Tractor Talk banner

1 - 7 of 7 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
58 Posts
Discussion Starter #1
Still deciding on my model and the X584 has my interest because of the all wheel steer. But I'd like the features of the EFI in the 590. Going with the 584 I'm I really losing something with the iTorque engine?

Also, the best pick for a deck. I understand there are three. The Accel Deep in 54" would you say its a better deck over the high capacity model? I want to try my hand at mulching and see how it goes before i spend a bundle on a hopper just yet.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
12,288 Posts
One could ask why there isn't EFI on all the X300 and X500 series? For some reason JD likes to charge a huge premium for that EFI engine so I suspect it would push the price of the other models over the top. I suspect sooner or later all small engines with electrical systems will be EFI.

There really isn't any reason for an EFI engine to cost more than one with a carb. Honda introduced the EFI version of its large portable generator and kept the price exactly the same as the previous carb model.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,877 Posts
I would go with the Accel deep deck.My dad has the 42" on his x370 and I can't believe how clean it stays and how nice the cut is.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
58 Posts
Discussion Starter #4
So going with the Accel Deep deck are there other advantages between the 48 and 54 besides the obvious? I know for the 700's this would eliminate the drive over feature but irrelevant here.

Mainly, I don't want a hulking deck in my garage (more for the other half to complain about) but keep all the features of the larger unit.
 

·
Premium Member
Joined
·
1,805 Posts
So going with the Accel Deep deck are there other advantages between the 48 and 54 besides the obvious? I know for the 700's this would eliminate the drive over feature but irrelevant here.

Mainly, I don't want a hulking deck in my garage (more for the other half to complain about) but keep all the features of the larger unit.
48inch Leave a better Looking Cut than the 54inch . I should Have Kept My 48inch deck from My X485 when I Upgraded to a X748. Because the 54inch On the X748 is Not the Best Looking Cut. I bought a Used 2004 GX335 off of eBay In 2016 I let the dealer Keep the 48inch deck and Put a 42inch Deck On it. Yes it Give's Me More seat time. But the 42inch is a even Better Looking Cut than the 48inch. The GX335 was Bought to Take Care of are Old Homes Property which we Had Planned On renting out. But ended Up Just Hiring a Old Neighbor & family Friend to Take Over the Mowing duties there :bigthumb:
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
3,333 Posts
One could ask why there isn't EFI on all the X300 and X500 series? For some reason JD likes to charge a huge premium for that EFI engine so I suspect it would push the price of the other models over the top. I suspect sooner or later all small engines with electrical systems will be EFI.

There really isn't any reason for an EFI engine to cost more than one with a carb. Honda introduced the EFI version of its large portable generator and kept the price exactly the same as the previous carb model.
If you want to ask that question what about looking at some other John Deere Equipment. It is easy to point to money and trying to hit a certain price point. Not saying that isn't part of the equation but look at the Z9xx series machines. There are a couple EFI options in the smaller engine sizes (and cost less money) but the bigger ones are all carb engines. In the case of my Z950R. Maybe Kawasaki doesn't make a vertical shaft 27HP engine with EFI. Kind of doubt it but sure enough it is a carb engine.

Sure they may be down on efficiency a bit but they are simpler as long as the cab stays clean. In the case of a commercial mower, the demand is probably there that people want something that will run and not have to worry about a finicky EFI. They have been around long enough to be pretty solid but my X585 was down for a couple weeks chasing a wire that had rubbed on the head of a bolt enough to wear through the insulation and short out the EFI system. Wouldn't have happened on a carb engine.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
34 Posts
It is a cost thing. A "X594" would be really close to a base X7, and in my experience folks usually jump up in those instances (even if they lose 4WS). Could happen though one day. I know the X590 has really taken sales from the X580.

In terms of commercial mowers, there are few if any large EFI engines, thus carbs in the big ones.
 
1 - 7 of 7 Posts
Top